The Shaken Baby Syndrome Myth
l
ife-threatening and legally shattering medical misdiagnosis

*
SBS: To date, an unproven medical hypothesis without supporting scientific evidence, depriving live infants of proper diagnosis and treatment, and caretakers of justice   * The diagnostic triad of symptoms aren't caused by shaking   * Accidental and medical causes of the same symptoms: short falls, accidental injury, hypoxia (oxygen deprivation) infection (encephalitis, etc.), metabolic diseases and other medical conditions, vaccine injury, birth injuries.......* Head impact: false criteria for amount of force required    * THE JOHN LAVERTY--BABY CASEY FAMILY TRAGEDY
HOME:  http://legaljustice4john.com


(this page is currently being re-written and edited)

THE JOHN LAVERTY-BABY CASEY FAMILY TRAGEDY

Mother of John's first childJohn & M.R. in 1998
at our family
Xmas party

John and older daughter, CC
John and first daughter
CC at a park in 1999

John Laverty had two daughters, CC, born in 1999, and Casey, born in 2000, 16 months apart. He was one of those rare men who just loves babies, dotes on them. and wasn't put off by dirty diapers, late nights, vomit, runny noses, crying, or sleepless nights.

He met the mother, M.R. (my daughter) of his first-born child in 1998 when they were both teenagers (photos on left). They planned to marry, but she was volatile where he was quieter and accommodating, and she admitted she was so "hormonal" after getting pregnant that their relationship suffered.

About a week before CC was born, John brought home a girl he met while working at a selling job after he was temporarily laid off from his trucking company job. Melissa Berest was homeless, so he offered her a place to stay.

According to M.R. for the entire week Melissa stayed with the couple, she refused the food she was offered and lived entirely on coffee.

John was an exceptionally loving father to CC while the parents were together. M.R. trusted him completely with CC and left her in his care several times, including for an overnight trip she took out of town. He happily took care of all of her needs. Her only complaint was his habit of bouncing her in his hands in play, needlessly fearing it would cause "Shaken Baby Syndrome", but this was apparently such a common occurrence that the National SBS website had to put a disclaimer on their site informing people that this DID NOT cause SBS because so many people had been reporting caretakers for doing this and similar acts while playing with their children.

Melissa-after prison
Melissa
Baby Casey, Mar.2001
2 1/2 months AFTER SBS diagnosis

Melissa had her eye on John and managed to orchestrate the end of his relationship with MR, after which John and Melissa became a couple, and she soon became pregnant herself.

Melissa and John lived with his Korean mother and stepfather for two different periods during her pregnancy. His stepfather reported that Melissa refused to eat the healthy food John's mother prepared and instead lived on 8-10 cups of coffee per day, sweetened with around two cups of sugar. He said she went through 5 lb bags of sugar every few days. John said she ate some junk food like cookies and chips, and occasionally had fast foods like hamburgers, fries and sodas. She was supplied with prenatal vitamins, but refused to take them. She was warned about smoking but continued to do so during and after her pregnancy. By the time she delivered, she had only gained 10 lbs.

Melissa had also suffered from iritis (a chronic infection of the iris of the eyes). When she gave birth, she hemorrhaged for two days. Eating disorders, iritis and abnormal bleeding are all symptoms found in Vitamin C deficiency.

The Poisoned Needle
While Melissa was being tended to medically for abnormal bleeding after delivery, John stayed in the hospital room and held the baby. Casey was born around 9PM. Doctors are required to wait 12 hours before vaccinating, so on her second day of life someone came in and pulled Baby Casey right out of her father's arms to be vaccinated.
He objected. His older child was unvaccinated because of a family history of life-threatening vaccine injuries, including a combined Staph and Strept infection in the blood that caused a flesh-eating infection so virulent that the whole family (family history)  became infected through contact. However, he was told "it's the law" and that he had no choice. Someone lied. Washington State allows medical, religious and personal exemptions, which was claimed for his older child, Casey's half-sister CC. Besides the flesh-eating disease the mother of his first child contracted immediately after her first and only vaccination, the grandmother got hepatitis twice following tetanus shots and was chronically ill after childhood vaccines, and the great grandfather got Yellow Fever from that vaccine. A cousin developed "Screaming syndrome" after her first shot, another cousin got measles after a measles shot, and a lot of other adverse effects were suspected. John had a valid reason for refusing shots for his children and the legal right to do so which was denied by a medical professional at Tacoma General Hospital.

John remembers hearing them say "triple vax"--a term he otherwise was unfamiliar with--but the records report only a Hepatitis B vaccination ...a vaccine so dangerous to newborns that the public in France staged demonstrations and a large group of people filed lawsuits for vaccine injury until Hep B was removed from the childhood vaccine schedule.

Doctors and nurses tend to look on the refusal to vaccinate infants and children as a form of child abuse or neglect, but a few quotes sum up the other side of the debate that few doctors ever question or research, or if they do, they don't tell--especially pediatricians, whose incomes come primarily from the infant and childhood shots.

**************************

  • Getting a vaccination does not guarantee immunity. (~CDC, January 28, 1994.)
  • "Neutralizing antibodies are reported to reflect levels of protection, although this has not been validated in the field." (~Journal of the American Medical Association, June 9, 1999, Vol. 281. No. 22)
  • Vaccines made from animal substrate contain animal viruses that are impossible to filter out. By 1961, scientists discovered that animal viruses in vaccines, including smallpox, could act as a carcinogen when given to mice in combination with cancer-causing chemicals, even in amounts too small to induce tumors alone. They concluded that vaccine viruses function as a catalyst for tumor production. (~Science, December 15, 1961.)
  • THE WASHINGTON POST, Feb.2, 1986 "Vaccines can be a risk for infected persons--virus in vaccines, like natural virus infection...MAY ACTIVATE LATENT VIRAL INFECTIONS."--Dr. Robert Gallo, National Institute of Health
  • By the 1920s, several British medical researchers documented that smallpox was not only more common among the VACCINATED, but that the DEATH RATE from smallpox was actually higher among those who had been vaccinated. This indicates that the vaccine was ineffective and predisposed vaccinated persons to more lethal disease. (~Vaccination, Dr. Viera Schreibner, 1993 pp. 205-220.)

  • Encyclopedia Americana Vol.27, P.852 (1986)  Vaccination Article
  BANNED IN AMERICA  The headlines and story featured in the London Times on May 5th, 1987 that we in the US were not allowed to read, reportedly due to a conspiracy of silence agreed to by top journalists and scientists at a secret meeting for the purpose of a cover-up.

When vaccines are mentioned, most people associate them with the eradication of polio and smallpox. Nothing could be further from the truth than the "revisionist" history we have all been spoon fed about these epidemics. Polio had three main world-wide epidemics in the twentieth century. The first two came and went as epidemics do. The third one we all hear about was nearly ended before the polio vaccine was introduced. It was only used in two countries, after which the numbers increased before going back into a decline, and those 7-8 year olds who were chosen for the mass vaccination cohort were in an age range least affected by polio, which only has serious side effects in 1/2 of 1% of those with the infection. The epidemic ended in unvaccinated countries without any intervention accept the development of cleaner water and better waste disposal systems as well more sanitary food supplies. Ask any surveyor. It's part of their professional history.

The polio vaccine was contaminated with a leukemia virus. After the mass vaccination of children, childhood leukemia, which was almost unknown prior to the polio vaccine afterward become one of the top 10 killers of children. For even worse information, look up SV-40 (SV40) and HeLa cells.

The WHO (World Health Organization) claim that vaccines eradicated smallpox was equally fictitious. The smallpox vaccine had a disastrous history from the beginning. Look up the past history of smallpox vaccine + Philippines. It triggered many epidemics of smallpox and other diseases and conditions. WHO field workers admitted in interviews for a book that the only thing that actually worked was the ancient practice of quarantine, and that "the real story would never be known". Even that didn't eradicate smallpox so they just renamed it "Monkeypox". That's how they "ended" smallpox.

*******************************

The Unauthorized Hep B Vaccination: Documented Adverse Effects
http://www.rxlist.com/recombivax-drug.htm

Symptoms: Studies involved observation for 5 days only

Pain, tenderness, pruritus, erythema, ecchymosis, swelling, warmth, nodule formation, irritability, fever ( = 101°F oral equivalent), diarrhea, fatigue/weakness, diminished appetite, rhinitis, nausea; pharyngitis, upper respiratory infection, sweating; achiness, sensation of warmth, lightheadedness; chills, flushing, vomiting; abdominal pains/cramps; dyspepsia; influenza, cough, vertigo/dizziness, paresthesia, pruritus, rash (non-specified); angioedema; urticaria, arthralgia including monoarticular, myalgia; back pain; neck pain, shoulder pain, neck stiffness, lymphadenopathy, insomnia/disturbed sleep, earache, dysuria, hypotension, elevation of liver enzymes, constipation, Guillain-Barré Syndrome, multiple sclerosis; exacerbation of multiple sclerosis; myelitis including transverse myelitis, seizure; febrile seizure; peripheral neuropathy including Bell's Palsy; radiculopathy; herpes zoster; migraine; muscle weakness; hypesthesia; encephalitis, Stevens-Johnson Syndrome; alopecia; petechiae, eczema, arthritis, increased erythrocyte sedimentation rate; thrombocytopenia, pain in extremity, systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE); lupus-like syndrome; vasculitis, polyarteritis nodosa, irritability; agitation; somnolence, optic neuritis, tinnitus, conjunctivitis, visual disturbances, syncope and tachycardia.

Hypersensitivity

Anaphylaxis and symptoms of immediate hypersensitivity reactions including rash, pruritus, urticaria, edema, angioedema, dyspnea, chest discomfort, bronchial spasm, palpitation, or symptoms consistent with a hypotensive episode have been reported within the first few hours after vaccination. An apparent hypersensitivity syndrome (serum-sickness-like) of delayed onset has been reported days to weeks after vaccination, including: arthralgia/arthritis (usually transient), fever, and dermatologic reactions such as urticaria, erythema multiforme, ecchymoses and erythema nodosum

Patients, parents and guardians should be instructed to report any serious adverse reactions to their healthcare provider, who in turn should report such events to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services through the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS), 1-800-822-7967.31

The government admits that only 1-10% of reactions are ever reported by doctors to VAERS. One symptom left out of this list, among others, is...death.

Hospitalization: Apnea
Casey was born on Nov. 20th, 2000. By Nov. 23, Thanksgiving Day, she had become lethargic and refused her bottle. Then she cried out and John ran to console the baby. As he held her, Baby Casey's eyes rolled back in her head, she became unresponsive to voice or finger-snapping, and she appeared to quit breathing temporarily. He noticed at that time that there was a yellow tint to her skin, and a bluish darkening (oxygen deprivation) around her mouth. They rushed her to Mary Bridge Children's Hospital, where no cause for the "apnea" (breathing stops) episode was officially listed.

The possibility of a vaccination adverse reaction was not even mentioned in the medical records even though doctors are required by law to report all reactions within 72 hours following vaccination to VAERS, the government's vaccine injury department, but even the government admits that only 1-10% of all known or suspected vaccine injuries are ever reported by doctors. The Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System does NOT publish reports from parents or caregivers. VAERS was created to help victims. Instead, it was adversarial from the beginning and works hard with a battery of attorneys to eliminate as many cases as possible--around 75% of them. Doctors know better than to report vaccine injuries or to even diagnose them. Careers and reputations are put at risk if they do. The pressure against such "whistle-blowing" is enormous.

The pediatric records, whether by careless error or criminal design, record Casey was vaccinated a day earlier than she was and admitted to the hospital a day later, effectively side-stepping the reporting period.

Under-reporting seems to be considered necessary to preserve the public "faith" in the mostly compulsory vaccine programs and to avoid personal blame and extremely expensive liability for "injury," although doctors are exempt and vaccine manufacturers refused to accept liability from the 1980's on and have forced the government to cover all claims, paying out over 1 billion dollars in damages for the small percentage of cases they could not succeed in dismissing. The government admits only 1-10% of cases are reported by doctors and less than 25% of those are compensated.

Heart Rate and Respiration Abnormalities
Casey was put on a heart and respiration monitor. At one point the numbers were so low that one doctor questioned whether the monitor had malfunctioned in some way, but Dr. Viera Schreibner of Australia noted the same abnormal readings on equipment when they monitored infants in a "cot watch" breathing pattern study, unexpectedly documenting that there were a series of key days of vaccine reactions that were worse than other days, and that these reactions could continue for a month. The vaccine connection was after the studies were evaluated, not before.

Breathing pattern studies that became vaccination "adverse reaction" studies
From the Cot watch graphs of Dr.Vera Schreibner
:
"It is obvious that even though baby one reacted much more than baby two (referring to computer chip read-outs on two infants she studied), the flare-ups of stressed breathing followed the same pattern of critical days, the most important of these being day 2, after which day the stress level went down and started rising again between days 5 and 7, when the stress level subsided and started increasing again between days 14-16, subsided again and rose again between days 19-24, after which it subsided and rose again towards the 28th day and so on, following closely the pattern of alarms as recorded by a mother of one baby (figure 1). Days 10 or 11 also emerged as critical days in babies who reacted strongly, such as baby one."

"One must also take into consideration that in statistics you always have a slight spread of a day or two before or after the critical days. One can also rephrase it that nature does not necessarily operate in a sudden, cut-off fashion but in a building-up and tapering-off way." --Dr. Vera Schreibner


"A Rare Blood Disease" (Sepsis) --No, No, "Hospital Error"
While Casey was in the hospital, blood work was done and a doctor told the parents she had "a rare blood disease" after she tested positive for strept and staph, just like the infection that nearly killed the mother of John's first child after her first vaccination. They put Baby Casey on IV antibiotics for 3 days. One doctor thought it was an apnea incident. Another physician, Later, after a lot of "poking and prodding" and no more findings of infection, Dr. C (who became their pediatrician) arbitrarily decided it was more likely a matter of contamination--a hospital error. It's more likely that the antibiotics cleared the infection from the blood, but the only way to verify that infection hadn't spread to the brain beyond the blood-brain barrier was to test the cerebral spinal fluid. They tried to do this twice but failed to collect any fluid. The symptoms she had, including lethargy (an indication of a brain neurological condition) are consistent with encephalitis among other things.

The matter of the antibiotics is something to consider. According to her medical records, after her blood tested positive for Strept and Staph, Baby Casey was put on Ampicillin and Ceftriaxone. AMPICILLIN. CEFTRIAXONE IS CONTERINDICATED FOR INFANTS WITH HIGH BILIRUBIN.

ADVERSE REACTIONS:

AMPICILLIN
Diarrhea; pain, swelling, or redness at injection site, black "hairy" tongue; inflammation and redness of the tongue; nausea; second infection; vomiting.Hemic and Lymphatic Systems– Anemia, thrombocytopenia, thrombocytopenic purpura, eosinophilia, leukopenia, and agranulocytosis have been reported during therapy with the penicillins. Skin rashes and urticaria have been reported frequently. A few cases of exfoliative dermatitis and erythema multiforme have been reported.Liver– A moderate rise in serum glutamic oxaloacetic transaminase (SGOT) has been noted, particularly in infants. Additional systemic reactions reported--itching, candidiasis, fatigue, malaise, headache, chest pain, flatulence, abdominal distension, glossitis, urine retention, dysuria, edema, facial swelling, erythema, chills, tightness in throat, substernal pain, epistaxis and mucosal bleeding. Hepatic: Increased AST (SGOT), ALT (SGPT), alkaline phosphatase, and LDH. Hematologic: Decreased hemoglobin, hematocrit, RBC, WBC, neutrophils, lymphocytes, platelets and increased lymphocytes, monocytes, basophils, eosinophils, and platelets. Blood Chemistry: Decreased serum albumin and total proteins. Renal: Increased BUN and creatinine.Urinalysis: Presence of RBC's and hyaline casts in urine. Gastrointestinal:
Gastritis, stomatitis, and enterocolitis. Onset of pseudomembranous colitis symptoms may occur during or after antibiotic treatment.

Pediatric Patients:Available safety data for pediatric patients treated with Ampicillin and Sulbactam demonstrate a similar adverse events profile to those observed in adult patients. Additionally, atypical lymphocytosis has been observed in one pediatric patient receiving Ampicillin and Sulbactam. Thrombophlebitis. Rash; hives; itching; difficulty breathing; tightness in the chest; swelling of the mouth, face, lips, or tongue; stomach pain or cramps; unusual bruising or bleeding; vaginal irritation or discharge; vein inflammation or tenderness; white patches in mouth.

http://www.peacehealth.org/kbase/cam/hn-1317001.htm: Summary of Interactions for Ampicillin--Depletion or interference Vitamin C*
Vitamin K*, Interactions with Supplements

Vitamin C: Test tube studies show that ampicillin significantly reduces the amount of vitamin C in the blood.1 Controlled research is needed to determine whether individuals might benefit from supplementing vitamin C while taking ampicillin.

1. Alabi ZO, Thomas KD, Ogunbona O, Elegbe IA. The effect of antibacterial agents on plasma vitamin C levels. Afr J Med Med 1994;23:143-6.
Vitamin K

Several cases of excessive bleeding have been reported in people who take antibiotics.7, 8, 9, 10 This side effect may be the result of reduced vitamin K activity and/or reduced vitamin K production by bacteria in the colon. One study showed that people who had taken broad-spectrum antibiotics had lower liver concentrations of vitamin K2 (menaquinone), though vitamin K1 (phylloquinone) levels remained normal.11 Several antibiotics appear to exert a strong effect on vitamin K activity, while others may not have any effect. Therefore, one should refer to a specific antibiotic for information on whether it interacts with vitamin K. Doctors of natural medicine sometimes recommend vitamin K supplementation to people taking antibiotics. Additional research is needed to determine whether the amount of vitamin K1 found in some multivitamins is sufficient to prevent antibiotic-induced bleeding. Moreover, most multivitamins do not contain vitamin K.
7. Suzuki K, Fukushima T, Meguro K, et al. Intracranial hemorrhage in an infant owing to vitamin K deficiency despite prophylaxis. Childs Nerv Syst 1999;15:292-4.
8. Huilgol VR, Markus SL, Vakil NB. Antibiotic-induced iatrogenic hemobilia. Am J Gastroenterol 1997;92:706-7.
9. Bandrowsky T, Vorono AA, Borris TJ, Marcantoni HW. Amoxicllin-related postextraction bleeding in an anticoagulated patient with tranexamic acid rinses. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod 1996;82:610-2.
10. Kaiser CW, McAuliffe JD, Barth RJ, Lynch JA. Hypoprothrombinemia and hemorrhage in a surgical patient treated with cefotetan. Arch Surg 1991;126:524-5.
11. Conly J, Stein K. Reduction of vitamin K2 concentration in human liver associated with the use of broad spectrum antimicrobials. Clin Invest Med 1994;17:531-9.

CEFTRIAXONE:
LOCAL REACTIONS—Phlebitis was reported in <1% after IV administration.
HYPERSENSITIVITY—rash (1.7%). Less frequently reported (<1%) were pruritus, fever or chills. HEMATOLOGIC—eosinophilia (6%), thrombocytosis (5.1%) and leukopenia (2.1%). Less frequently reported (<1%) were anemia, hemolytic anemia, neutropenia, lymphopenia, thrombocytopenia and prolongation of the prothrombin time.
GASTROINTESTINAL—diarrhea (2.7%). Less frequently reported (<1%) were nausea or vomiting, and dysgeusia. The onset of pseudomembranous colitis symptoms may occur during or after antibacterial treatment (see WARNINGS). HEPATIC—elevations of SGOT (3.1%) or SGPT (3.3%). Less frequently reported (<1%) were elevations of alkaline phosphatase and bilirubin. RENAL—elevations of the BUN (1.2%). Less frequently reported (<1%) were elevations of creatinine and the presence of casts in the urine.CENTRAL NERVOUS SYSTEM—headache or dizziness were reported occasionally (<1%).GENITOURINARY—moniliasis or vaginitis were reported occasionally (<1%). MISCELLANEOUS—diaphoresis and flushing were reported occasionally (<1%).

Other adverse reactions include abdominal pain, agranulocytosis, allergic pneumonitis, anaphylaxis, basophilia, biliary lithiasis, bronchospasm, colitis, dyspepsia, epistaxis, flatulence, gallbladder sludge, glycosuria, hematuria, jaundice, leukocytosis, lymphocytosis, monocytosis, nephrolithiasis, palpitations, a decrease in the prothrombin time, renal precipitations, seizures, and serum sickness.

ENDOTOXIN RELEASE FROM ANTIBIOTIC OR VACCINE USE, OR FOLLOWING INFECTION

Different endotoxin release and IL-6 plasma levels after antibiotic administration in surgical intensive care patients
Holzheimer, RG; Hirte, JF; Reith, B; Engelhardt, W; Horak, KH; Leppert, R; Aasen, A; Capel, P; Urbaschek, R; Karch, H; Thiede, A Journal of Endotoxin Research [J. ENDOTOXIN RES.]. Vol. 3, no. 3. 1996.

      "Despite the use of broad-spectrum antibiotics, aggressive fluid resuscitation, vasopressor support, the mortality associated with Gram-negative sepsis and septic shock has not decreased significantly in the last two decades. The consequences of host exposure to endotoxin and the relationship of antibiotic administration to endotoxin release have become important areas of intense interest. In vitro studies have demonstrated that there was a difference in endotoxin release between PBP-3 specific antibiotics ( beta -lactam antibiotics) and PBP-2 specific antibiotics (carbapenems). This is the first clinical report of surgical patients admitted to the surgical and anaesthesiology intensive care unit on the missing endotoxin release after imipenem treatment; however cefotaxime and ceftriaxone showed significantly more positive endotoxin tests in the plasma when compared to imipenem. Ciprofloxacin and vancomycin were intermediate in endotoxin release and tobramycin did not cause endotoxin release. There were also significant differences in endotoxin neutralizing capacity. IL-6 levels were decreased after imipenem faster than after ceftriaxone or cefotaxime; ciprofloxacin seemed to increase IL-6. Endotoxin may be harmful in patients where the immune system has been continuously challenged. Timing, dosage, or combination with other compounds as well as the effect of antibiotics on macrophages need to be tested in larger clinical trials. In this respect a consecutive study was started. "

ADVERSE EFFECTS OF ENDOTOXINS: (toxins released from bacteria cells walls when they die)

http://www.freeyurko.bizland.com/kaloksb1.html  (Dr. Archie Kalokerinos, M.D.)

  • Endotoxin can in itself, cause coagulation/bleeding disorders.
  • Endotoxin uses vast quantities of Vitamin C while being ‘detoxified’ (involving free radical reactions).
  • Vitamin C deficiency can, in itself, cause haemorrhages.
  • Vitamin C deficiency can, in itself, cause spontaneous fractures.

Endotoxin can target the brain by:
1. specifically, and selectively, damaging the endothelial linings of cerebral blood vessels
2. breaking the blood-brain barrier
3. seeping into the cerebral tissue
4. causing anoxia by a direct effect on the respiratory centre
5. initiating a rapid series of biochemical disturbances, including free radical reactions, leading to an extremely rapid onset of cerebral edema—with a host of possible complications
6. causing coagulation/bleeding disturbances.

High Bilirubin and Jaundice
Baby Casey was, however, unquestionably diagnosed with a high bilirubin count and jaundice, considered "normal" in newborns but which usually resolves in 3-4 days, not many days later as it did in Baby Casey. Dr. C. also claimed "breast milk" was "probably" the cause of the high bilirubin and jaundice. However, both apnea and these these conditions are also linked to vaccine injury, as well as junk food and excess sugar in the diet. He wasn't even aware that because of Melissa's scanty supply of pumped breast (she gave up nursing as quickly as possible because of the discomfort), John had almost immediately put Baby Casey on baby formula as her main food supply, and chose soy formula due to a family history of dairy intolerance. (There are medical journal accounts of soy formula alone causing Barlow's disease--infantile scurvy.)

"Extremely high levels of bilirubin in infants may cause kernicterus, a form of brain damage. Signs of severe hyperbilirubinemia include listlessness, high-pitched crying, apnea (periods of not breathing), arching of the back, and seizures. If severe hyperbilirubinemia is not treated, it can cause mental retardation, hearing loss, behavior disorders, cerebral palsy, or death."

Urine Tint
According the the medical record, Casey's urine test came up abnormal. On online check revealed that it could be associated with bone absorption.

First Sign of Abnormal Bruising
At the end of Baby Casey's extended hospital stay, one of the medical attendants who drew blood from her foot held her leg to do so and left a bruise there, in a first sign of possible "abnormal bruising". John saw it and confronted the man about it, but it was shrugged off.

John Laverty worked long, hard hours to earn a good living for a young man his age, but when his baby daughter lost consciousness and appeared to stop breathing soon after birth, he rushed her to the hospital and took time off work to stay in the room with her day and night, to find out what was wrong and to make sure she was properly cared for and never left alone right up until his boss threatened to fire him if he didn't come back to work, but only Casey appeared to be out of danger. He was not not happy with all of the poking and prodding done, with no clear answers about what had happened. And he was not happy that a medic had bruised his child.

The pediatrician told the parents if they wanted to retain him as Casey's doctor, to call him in a few days at the pediatric clinic where he had his office for an "after-hospital" checkup. John lost the number but was finally able to track it down later. When he called, the doctor had gone on vacation and instead of being referred to another doctor, he was told they would have to wait until the doctor returned.

The Nurse Consulation Phone Service
As Casey was being discharged from Mary Bridge Children's Hospital (the children's wing of Tacoma General Hospital) on Nov. 27th, 2000 after five days in the hospital, a nurse handed John and Melissa a white business card with an 800 number to a nurse consultation phone service under contract with the hospital to call for any health concerns. While waiting for the doctor to return from vacation, they had occasion to call the nursing "hotline" a number of times.

A Home Visiting Nurse Comes To Check On Baby Casey
The day after Casey got home from the hospital, Nurse Kristin Schmidt came to see the family. Her later report on this visit:

Symptoms Following Baby Casey's Release From The Hospital
The first apparent life-threatening event--apnea--occurred on Thanksgiving Day, Nov. 23, 2000 making it 2 days after the Hep B vaccination on Nov. 21. The first sign of abnormal bruising, seen after Casey's leg was held to draw blood from her foot, was around Monday, day 7 after the shot. By the time Casey was released after 5 days, her behavior had begun to deteriorate, but there was nothing specific for the next few days that John could remember, except that she remained lethargic--a "sleepy baby" while at the same time more fussy and irritable. By day 14 or so, Casey had taken a noticeable turn for the worse and had become even more lethargic and sleepy, irritable, had a "creepy way of turning her heels in" as John described it, and was far more fussy when held.

Melissa would leave Casey in the bassinet all day, but as soon as John came home from work he wanted to be with his daughter for the rest of the night. Even Melissa later remarked that he was a little jealous because she got to be with Casey all day while he had to work. She couldn't handle dirty diapers, so as soon as he got home he took Casey in to change her diaper at the same time he got out of his work clothes. He fed her, bathed her, and spent the rest of the night holding her while he watched tv. She was more fussy when being held, but John thought it was because he was gone all day and she "forgot" him. He had no way of knowing that her symptoms, particularly the frog-leg posture, were classic signs of Barlow's disease, and that subperiosteal hemorrhaging in the legs was the cause of the posture due to intense pain aggrevated by movement.

Temporary Change In Casey's Skull Shape
As John tells it, a frightening thing happened a few days before the most acute symptoms began. He came home from work and noticed that Baby Casey had something going on with her head. He said,  "Well, like her head was elongating and turning into a 'cone head' shape.'' He called the nurse's hotline immediately and the nurse laughed it off and assured him it was just a temporary condition caused by the baby lying on her side too long.  The was the position the doctor at the hospital told the parents to use because she was a "shallow breather." He was told to lay her on her back and "go to bed." The next day her skull shape was back to normal.

There are accounts of babies developing flat spots on the back of their heads from sleeping on their backs. Their skulls are still relatively soft in infancy. But this is also something that happens to babies with Vitamin D deficiency. According to medical literature, bone disease starts with abnormal thinning of the sides and back of the skull, and if it persists, individuals with this deficiency can develop characteristic dome-shaped skulls with "bossed" (protruding) foreheads, which describes Casey's appearance in photos several months later. Rickets or subclinical rickets have other diagnostic signs and symptoms. Historically, scurvy and rickets were often found together.

Casey Becomes Acutely IIll Late At Night After Christmas Shopping
On Tuesday 12-12-00, 21 days after her vaccination, Baby Casey became acutely ill from respiratory problems with severe lung congestion and difficulty breathing. John and Melissa had bundled her up and went out to do some shopping. Around 11pm that night Casey had become congested and her breathing was labored, so John called the hotline. The nurse said it was just a bad cold and they didn't need to bring her in. Melissa stayed on the phone with the nurse who talked John through the Baby Heimlich Manuever for choking to help Baby Casey cough up the mucus that was making it hard for her to breath. It required back-patting off and on all night, about once an hour. She coughed up white froth and he would suction it out of her mouth until the last time about 5am in the morning, when a yellow mucus plug came up. After that she was able to sleep. When he left for work about 6am, she was resting peacefully when he kissed her goodby.

When John came home that evening, on Wednesday, at 22 days, he saw a small sore at the corner of her mouth and her eyes were bloodshot with red lids. Melissa told him she had started this high-pitched crying around noon and her eyes got red after that. He called the nursing hotline to talk about it, and they assured him it was "colic" and "red eyes from crying" and that Casey "didn't need to be seen."

Then she developed this brown discoloration under her lower lip that looked like she had been "eating chocolate amd drooled". He wondered if it was "wind burn" from being out in the weather the evening before, even though he had her warmly dressed and wrapped. The next morning it had separated into four distinct "messy sores" at the corners of her mouth on each side with two more rimming her lower lip, spaced almost equally apart. John called the hotline again about the sores. The nurse said it was just cold sores, and to keep A&D lotion on it. Also, that she "didn't need to be seen." He kept the clear, greasy lotion on the sores right up through the time the went to a pediatric appointment the following Monday. The doctor had finally returned from vacation and called them to set the time. It was supposed to have been a hospital follow-up but he scheduled it as a one month "well-baby" appointment.

At 23 days, (Thursday) John came home and noticed a little bit of blood in Casey's saliva. He figured she was teething and just suctioned it out and didn't bother the nurse. It did not recur. Around 24-25 days after her shot, the diarrhea started. Casey had remained congested and fussy with the high-pitched crying, and still had noisy breathing, but didn't seem to be as ill as she was the first night. No fever--just congested respiration and a runny nose. He also noticed that she had been grunting.

On Friday night, Dec. 15th, John was alone with the baby for the first time. Melissa had gone out to have coffee with her estranged mother and left Casey with John. He was sitting on the bed playing with her by holding her horizontally and bouncing her in his hands to make her laugh. He doesn't know how it happened, but she slipped through his hands. Her fall was broken by a padded laundry basket beside him on to a carpeted floor. She quit crying as soon as he grabbed her up and hugged her to his chest in a panic, and she didn't have a bump or bruise on her after bumping her head on the rim of the laundry basket, but he immediately called the nurse's hotline, told them what happened, and asked what to do. The nurse went through a detailed checklist for any sign of injury, decided there was none and told him it wasn't necessary to bring her in to be seen.

Baby Casey was sleeping peacefully when Melissa and her mother returned. She didn't know anything had happened and John didn't volunteer the information, particularly when he had done it before in front of her and she got mad. In fact, he had done the same thing with his older daughter several times, and her mother had a fit too, and told him to do it by pumping his arms up and down with her instead of bouncing her in the flat of his hands.

On Saturday (Dec. 16th, 2000) John's mother and stepfather came to visit. When I asked the stepfather how she seemed at that time, he said she was lethargic as usual, but otherwise "fine".

When John got home from work the next day (Sunday), he noticed a red spot on Casey's left cheek and asked Melissa about it. Melissa thought it was from the day before when John's mother was holding the baby to her chest were she had a scarf pin, and that had left a mark. But photographs taken a day or so later show it as an erupting pimple or whitehead, so it was just a swelling where she was breaking out. However, Melissa later told CPS that she had been holding Baby Casey when she bumped into a wall or doorjamb that day or evening, also. She didn't tell John about it at the time, but he didn't notice anything different when he came home other than the spot on her cheek.

The next morning they had the pediatric appointment. It was John's day off so he ran errands in the morning and then drove Melissa (Melissa couldn't drive) and Baby Casey to the clinic an hour early. The appointment was at 10:15 and they were there a little after 9am. John remembers that Casey was "in a good mood", an alert "happy baby" the day they went to the well-baby appointment on Dec.18th, 2000, 27 days after her shot. He carried her inside in the car seat, but she got fussy when being handled at the clinic.

The Medical Assistant Discusses The Parent's Health Concerns
The doctor's Medical Assistant, Shelly LaVergne came out and talked to the parents and looked at Casey. John and Melissa were telling her about what had been going on--a bad cold, colic, etc. The M.A. also thought the 4 skin lesions were cold sores, but was concerned about the red eyes and eyelids and agreed to make certain the doctor discussed all of this with them. Then she had John undress Casey and lay her on a cold examining table. Casey let out an "ear-splitting scream" and began what the M.A. described as "inconsolable high-pitched crying" that alarmed her. She went in and told the doctor she thought something was wrong. John was concerned too. He thought maybe the cold surface had set her off because she had always been kept warm and wrapped up, but he wanted answers to his health concerns, although the nurses had continually told him it was just a bad cold, colic, red eyes from crying and cold sores. Melissa was also concerned about how little of her bottle Casey was taking at a time which she described as about a half ounce.

When the pediatrician came out, he kept trying to talk to Melissa, but she was a "Special Ed" kid who didn't even know what kind of Baby Formula they were using. John was the experienced parent who had to teach her everything from scratch, and the primary caretaker for all practical purposes, so if she didn't know something, John would answer, or correct her if she "fibbed" like claiming she was breast-feeding when she wasn't. Things weren't going well between the doctor and John. John was distrustful because of his previous experience with the hospital and doctors, and the doctor was perturbed that John was taking the lead when he expected the mother of the child to do so. John told him about everything, including the temporary skull deformation, which didn't seem to faze him. He finally--in reference to the skin lesions and red eyes--mumbled something about "child abuse" and said he was sending Casey to the hospital to "get checked out". Neither parent was happy about Casey going back to the same hospital and doctors who had botched her earlier stay, particularly since they had been assured by hotline nurses for days that Casey didn't even need to be seen.

John was also overheard saying the doctor was just doing it "for the money", which got back to the doctor. He had someone call an ambulance around 11:45am, and then called the police but only to meet the ambulance in case the parents tried to interfere with her being admitted to the hospital, which he later stated along with an admission that there hadn't been any trouble. They wanted to go in the ambulance with Casey, but the EMT's told them they weren't allowed to, besides which John had the car and needed to drive it to the hospital. Apparently Melissa was afraid to go in it anyway, telling someone because it "went too fast".

The Medical Assistant's Report

TRANSCRIBED REPORT: This was the first person to observe and examine baby Casey at the "well-baby" visit  with the pedicatrician at the Northwest Pediatrics clinic on December 18th, 2000.

Called parents back--FOB (father of baby) carrying baby, MOB (mother of baby) carrying bag and car seat. Asked routine questions--normal pregnancy, yes: Induced or spontaneous. delivery--mom looked puzzled and looked at FOB--he responded with, "they broke her H20". Asked if breast-fed or formula-fed. MOB replied breast and FOB replied formula-then MOB said is given formula @ times. MOB wasn't sure of name of formula. FOB replied Similac.

FOB was asking about "red marks" on baby's eyes. MOB said she contacted the Mary Bridge nurse because MOB has "arthritis" [sic] and she (MOB) that the eye redness was arthritis (Melissa was saying "iritis"). FOB and MOB said baby has been crying a lot and maybe the eyes (then FOB showed me the baby's eyelids that were red and discolored) could be from the baby crying.

FOB asked about the blisters on baby chin. I asked what happened. FOB said they (MOB and FOB and baby) went shopping on Tuesday 12/12/00. Baby started coughing and FOB said the next day she had the blisters. MOB said she (baby) had the blisters after they got back from shopping. MOB said she called the nurse @ Mary Bridge Hospital and told her about the blisters and the nurse said she has a cold and doesn't need to be seen.

FOB still holding baby while sitting down on bench. FOB placed baby against his chest. FOB was wearing a white furry jacket. Baby's face was against the fur. MOB told FOB to move her head because MOB was afraid she would inhale some of the fuzzy jacket. FOB stated if she (the baby) couldn't breath then she (the baby) would turn her own head.

MOB started talking about the baby being hospitalized for one week because the baby stopped breathing. FOB said the doctors all thought she had some kind of rare blood disease and she (the baby) had to be "poked" and FOB said "She had all kinds of shit done to her." FOB said they still weren't sure what's wrong with her.

Baby cried every time FOB moved her. I asked if baby usually cries this much. MOB said yes. I asked even when baby came home from the hospital? MOB replied "no, she has always cried and my mother says she has colic. But the cry has been louder the last 2-3 days." FOB replied that the baby "must have a cold."

I asked FOB and MOB to undress the baby down to her diaper so that I can weigh her, get her length and check her head circumference. FOB laid baby on table to undress her. Baby screamed piercing cry. I asked MOB if the baby usually cried like that. She said yes. The MOB & FOB wanted to know if I thought the baby had colic? I said I would make a note of it and Dr. Clapper would be able to give them an answer. MOB looked over at the baby and MOB said to FOB, "you can't hold her like that because you left a red mark on her face". I looked at baby's face and there was a small red mark on baby's left cheek. FOB said he didn't touch her there, but he held her head still by (then he showed me and MOB) placing his left thumb on baby's right side of the temporal lobe and placed his finger to the left side of the baby's temporal lobe. I did not see any marks. MOB asked why the baby would get marks so easily? I said that the baby has sensitive skin and we have to be gentle with them.

FOB finished undressing the baby (while the baby cried). The FOB carried the baby to the scale. I weighed the baby. I told FOB to take the baby back to the room. He did and laid the baby on the table. Once the FOB left the baby to still (?). Baby stopped crying. I picked up the baby so I could turn her to get her length. She cried. FOB and MOB were standing next to me. I asked again if she always cries with that high pitch. MOB replied, "She's just tired and has a cold." I finished measuring her and told the FOB and MOB to wrap the baby in a blanket and Doctor Clapper would be in shortly.

I left the room and told Dr. Clapper that I thought there was something wrong with the baby because of the high pitch cries and the frequency of crying.

I was putting the chart together and MOB came out of the room by herself and said she was concerned about how little the baby seemed to be eating. I asked how much does she eat & MOB replied 1/2 ounce to 1 ounce every hour. I asked when the baby eats the 1/2 to 1 ounce what does she (the baby) do? MOB replied, "she falls asleep." I told MOB that I would let Dr. Clapper know and he would give his advice to how much he thought the baby should eat. She went back to the room.

After putting the paperwork for the baby together I went in their room to give them the baby's measurements. FOB had the baby on the table. I looked at the baby and she had what appeared to me was Vaseline on her chin where the blisters were. I asked the FOB what was on her, he replied "A & D ointment;" that the nurse @ Mary Bridge told him to apply the ointment.

Dr. Clapper asked if I would get an O2Sat (?) on baby. I went in there. MOB was very upset and crying. FOB was holding baby. I told them what I was going to do. MOB said she knew about that from when they went to the hospital for one week. FOB replied that this was stupid and that there was nothing wrong with the baby. MOB replied she was extremely tired of last time she was at the hospital because the nurses @ T6 (Mary Bridge) kept waking MOB up every two hours to feed the baby. She seemed to be irritated about this. MOB replied saying Dr. Clapper is over-reacting and that the baby just has a cold, and there is nothing wrong with her. FOB seemed to be angry. I asked if they wanted to talk with Dr. Clapper again, they said no. After getting the 02SAT-which I told the parents it was100% MOB said that having the baby go in the ambulance was "freaking" (her?) out. MOB asked if they could take the baby by their car. I told them I couldn't override what Dr. Clapper had said and if they wanted to talk to Dr. Clapper again and MOB asked ROB who was looking out the window and just shrugged his shoulders. MOB started crying again and said she would like to talk to Dr. Clapper.

When paramedics arrived FOB and MOB stayed seated on the bench. After the paramedics took her away. MOB was crying. Neither FOB or MOB went with the baby in the ambulance. FOB and MOB left after the baby was gone.

Back To Mary Bridge Children's Hospital
John didn't think anything was seriously wrong, so he dropped Melissa off at the hospital. They arrived the same time the ambulance did, and Melissa carried her in to be admitted, telling the nurse the doctor wanted her checked out. John went on home to pack a bag for them, and stayed for a while cleaning up the apartment before he went back, until Melissa told him to get back to the hospital after a couple of hours--he had washed dishes, picked up and was about to do some laundry when she called him and ordered him back in a way that communicated trouble.

More editing...............(will finish this in the next few days)

 

Melissa probably had no idea of the damaging effects of her eating habits and the smoking which includes interference with the absorption of iron, calcium, other minerals and vitamins necessary to the developing fetus, particularly vitamins K and C. She reportedly grew up with a deficient diet. Along with smoking, this type of prolonged nutritional deficiency state passes on to an unborn child, potentially resulting in or contributing to the often fatal Cheadle-Möller-Barlow syndrome (Barlow's disease, Barlow disease, Möller-Barlow disease--infantile scurvy) which is characterized by gingival lesions (only when teeth are present), arthralgia, loss of appetite and weight loss, listlessness, bone abnormalities (beading on the ribs and other bones) that can be misread as healing fractures and actual spontaneous fractures, or those that occur from normal handling or minor mishaps, or major unseen fractures from birth injuries, bleeding internally, hemorrhages, abnormal bruising, redness, swelling, blisters, slow healing, an abnormal frog-leg position, and high-pitched crying among other symptoms, all of which have been written about by the internationally-known physician, the late Dr. C.A.B. Clemetson among others, thanks mostly to the ground-breaking work and published writings of world-famous Australian physician, Dr. Archie Kalokerinos, M.D. Apart from nutritional deficiencies, other triggering factors such as infection or the introduction of foreign proteins through vaccination are believed by some researchers to accelerate fulminating scurvy, causing a Barlow's disease variant which appears to progress much faster than normal infantile scurvy. (World-wide medical journal articles.) This accelerated condition is now referred to as Clemetson-Kalokerinos Syndrome by a group of physicians familiar with the research and findings, who are not threatened by the association with vaccine "adverse events".

Melissa herself appears to have suffered from deficiency symptoms. She mentioned iritis to the pediatrician's assistant (who mistakenly thought the father had this condition), possibly associated with vitamin C deficiency. It was a painful condition she suffered from most of her life. Under stress and with this type of eating habits she likely harbored many deficiency states which may have contributed to her own earlier diagnosis of hyperactivity, learning disabilities and abnormal behavior which led to a determination that she was "unfit for trial" in an unrelated case that was settled by a guilty plea in the middle of this case. This finding was overlooked or ignored in both of her cases.

As previously reported, Baby Casey was taken and injected with the Hep B vax over the objection of her father while her mother was being tended to for abnormal bleeding after delivery. The parents were given no information about possible side effects or signs to worry about, nor told to contact her physician if any of the known symptoms appeared. One of the documented side effects--apnea, occurred soon after. Connections have been made between a junk food, refined sugar diet, and vaccinations, and high bilirubin levels in the newborn and adults also. In fact, bilirubin increases have been linked to vaccines. The high bilirubin count may have contributed to the apnea. Other symptoms associated with high bilirubin are: listlessness, high-pitched crying, arching of the back, and seizures.

 

Following the Hep B vaccination and apnea incident, Baby Casey developed a cascade of symptoms. We spent months with John remembering what he could and answering my questions. At one point, I asked without any explanation (8-8-07) if he had noticed any unusual "frog leg" postures, John said, "Yes, she had this way of turning her heels under that was creepy to look at." The frog leg posture is pathognomic of Barlow's disease. Later on, after she was put into foster care immediately upon leaving the hospital, and when we arranged a visit, the foster mom said Casey "didn't like to be held." I also noticed when someone was holding her on their hip in a position that would normally involve a little one clamping her knees around someone's waist, that her legs seemed to splay out abnormally and wondered about that, along with a stiff-legged look apparent in one of the photos I took of her that day. Many other details came up as we spoke over time that John hadn't thought of until we were going through day-by-day accounts or realized had any significance.

 

The pediatrician filled out the clinic report marking everything as normal to begin with and then went back later and altered it.


The following are transcribed medical notes from that day. Some of them appear to have been changed, and some things were added that were not observed or reported in error at the pediatric clinic, according to an opthomologist's report soon after.

  • Alert and vigorous, crying
  • Head: normal fontanelle, bruise ecchymoses (R) zygoma (there was nothing on her right zygoma [cheekbone] until after she was taken from her parents at the clinic)
  • "Something-type (??) lesions" lower lip (skin sores) Began as chocolate brown discoloration, next day erupted into sores
  • Lung congestion: "??? rales" (spot on lungs from infection later described as probable lung "contusion" (bruise)
  • "Irritable crying not consolable" described the distinctive cry that concerned the nurse in terms less recognizable than "inconsolable high-pitched crying" usually associated with brain swelling/encephalitis caused by vaccine adverse reactions
  • Crying/fussy onset last week, had ??? (can't read)
  • Ecchymoses over eyelids
  • Ears--OK (they were not ok after she was handled at the hospital--concerns listed on forensic report)
  • Breast feeds: Melissa was unable to nurse, only had scant milk to pump --Casey was fed mostly soy formula (dairy intolerance in family)
  • Cries a lot, sleeps ok
  • Subscleral hemorrhages?
  • Fundal hemorrhages?

Below is an excerpt from the official report of ophthalmologist Clark W. Deem, MD, called in to check for
expected retinal hemorrhages. No subscleral, fundal or retinal hemorrhages found. Click for full report.

However, the pediatrician later told detectives he noted swelling on her head, labored breathing, and described her eyes as hemorrhaged and her eyelids as black.